Identify error-sensitive patterns by decision tree

© Springer International Publishing Switzerland 2015. When errors are inevitable during data classification, finding a particular part of the classification model which may be more susceptible to error than others, when compared to finding an Achilles’ heel of the model in a casual way, may help uncover specific error-sensitive value patterns and lead to additional error reduction measures. As an initial phase of the investigation, this study narrows the scope of problem by focusing on decision trees as a pilot model, develops a simple and effective tagging method to digitize individual nodes of a binary decision tree for node-level analysis, to link and track classification statistics for each node in a transparent way, to facilitate the identification and examination of the potentially “weakest” nodes and error-sensitive value patterns in decision trees, to assist cause analysis and enhancement development. This digitization method is not an attempt to re-develop or transform the existing decision tree model, but rather, a pragmatic node ID formulation that crafts numeric values to reflect the tree structure and decision making paths, to expand post-classification analysis to detailed node-level. Initial experiments have shown successful results in locating potentially high-risk attribute and value patterns; this is an encouraging sign to believe this study worth further exploration

Ensembles of jittered association rule classifiers

The ensembling of classifiers tends to improve predictive accuracy. To obtain an ensemble with N classifiers, one typically needs to run N learning processes. In this paper we introduce and explore Model Jittering Ensembling, where one single model is perturbed in order to obtain variants that can be used as an ensemble. We use as base classifiers sets of classification association rules. The two methods of jittering ensembling we propose are Iterative Reordering Ensembling (IRE) and Post Bagging (PB). Both methods start by learning one rule set over a single run, and then produce multiple rule sets without relearning. Empirical results on 36 data sets are positive and show that both strategies tend to reduce error with respect to the single model association rule classifier. A bias–variance analysis reveals that while both IRE and PB are able to reduce the variance component of the error, IRE is particularly effective in reducing the bias component. We show that Model Jittering Ensembling can represent a very good speed-up w.r.t. multiple model learning ensembling. We also compare Model Jittering with various state of the art classifiers in terms of predictive accuracy and computational efficiency.This work was partially supported by FCT project Rank! (PTDC/EIA/81178/2006) and by AdI project Palco3.0 financed by QREN and Fundo Europeu de Desenvolvimento Regional (FEDER), and also supported by Fundacao Ciencia e Tecnologia, FEDER e Programa de Financiamento Plurianual de Unidades de I & D. Thanks are due to William Cohen for kindly providing the executable code for the SLIPPER implementation. Our gratitude goes also to our anonymous reviewers who have helped to significantly improve this paper by sharing their knowledge and their informed criticism with the authors

DNA Molecule Classification Using Feature Primitives

BACKGROUND: We present a novel strategy for classification of DNA molecules using measurements from an alpha-Hemolysin channel detector. The proposed approach provides excellent classification performance for five different DNA hairpins that differ in only one base-pair. For multi-class DNA classification problems, practitioners usually adopt approaches that use decision trees consisting of binary classifiers. Finding the best tree topology requires exploring all possible tree topologies and is computationally prohibitive. We propose a computational framework based on feature primitives that eliminates the need of a decision tree of binary classifiers. In the first phase, we generate a pool of weak features from nanopore blockade current measurements by using HMM analysis, principal component analysis and various wavelet filters. In the next phase, feature selection is performed using AdaBoost. AdaBoost provides an ensemble of weak learners of various types learned from feature primitives. RESULTS AND CONCLUSION: We show that our technique, despite its inherent simplicity, provides a performance comparable to recent multi-class DNA molecule classification results. Unlike the approach presented by Winters-Hilt et al., where weaker data is dropped to obtain better classification, the proposed approach provides comparable classification accuracy without any need for rejection of weak data. A weakness of this approach, on the other hand, is the very "hands-on" tuning and feature selection that is required to obtain good generalization. Simply put, this method obtains a more informed set of features and provides better results for that reason. The strength of this approach appears to be in its ability to identify strong features, an area where further results are actively being sought

PepDist: A New Framework for Protein-Peptide Binding Prediction based on Learning Peptide Distance Functions

BACKGROUND: Many different aspects of cellular signalling, trafficking and targeting mechanisms are mediated by interactions between proteins and peptides. Representative examples are MHC-peptide complexes in the immune system. Developing computational methods for protein-peptide binding prediction is therefore an important task with applications to vaccine and drug design. METHODS: Previous learning approaches address the binding prediction problem using traditional margin based binary classifiers. In this paper we propose PepDist: a novel approach for predicting binding affinity. Our approach is based on learning peptide-peptide distance functions. Moreover, we suggest to learn a single peptide-peptide distance function over an entire family of proteins (e.g. MHC class I). This distance function can be used to compute the affinity of a novel peptide to any of the proteins in the given family. In order to learn these peptide-peptide distance functions, we formalize the problem as a semi-supervised learning problem with partial information in the form of equivalence constraints. Specifically, we propose to use DistBoost [1,2], which is a semi-supervised distance learning algorithm. RESULTS: We compare our method to various state-of-the-art binding prediction algorithms on MHC class I and MHC class II datasets. In almost all cases, our method outperforms all of its competitors. One of the major advantages of our novel approach is that it can also learn an affinity function over proteins for which only small amounts of labeled peptides exist. In these cases, our method's performance gain, when compared to other computational methods, is even more pronounced. We have recently uploaded the PepDist webserver which provides binding prediction of peptides to 35 different MHC class I alleles. The webserver which can be found at is powered by a prediction engine which was trained using the framework presented in this paper. CONCLUSION: The results obtained suggest that learning a single distance function over an entire family of proteins achieves higher prediction accuracy than learning a set of binary classifiers for each of the proteins separately. We also show the importance of obtaining information on experimentally determined non-binders. Learning with real non-binders generalizes better than learning with randomly generated peptides that are assumed to be non-binders. This suggests that information about non-binding peptides should also be published and made publicly available

Finding motif pairs in the interactions between heterogeneous proteins via bootstrapping and boosting

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>Supervised learning and many stochastic methods for predicting protein-protein interactions require both negative and positive interactions in the training data set. Unlike positive interactions, negative interactions cannot be readily obtained from interaction data, so these must be generated. In protein-protein interactions and other molecular interactions as well, taking all non-positive interactions as negative interactions produces too many negative interactions for the positive interactions. Random selection from non-positive interactions is unsuitable, since the selected data may not reflect the original distribution of data.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>We developed a bootstrapping algorithm for generating a negative data set of arbitrary size from protein-protein interaction data. We also developed an efficient boosting algorithm for finding interacting motif pairs in human and virus proteins. The boosting algorithm showed the best performance (84.4% sensitivity and 75.9% specificity) with balanced positive and negative data sets. The boosting algorithm was also used to find potential motif pairs in complexes of human and virus proteins, for which structural data was not used to train the algorithm. Interacting motif pairs common to multiple folds of structural data for the complexes were proven to be statistically significant. The data set for interactions between human and virus proteins was extracted from BOND and is available at <url>http://virus.hpid.org/interactions.aspx</url>. The complexes of human and virus proteins were extracted from PDB and their identifiers are available at <url>http://virus.hpid.org/PDB_IDs.html</url>.</p> <p>Conclusion</p> <p>When the positive and negative training data sets are unbalanced, the result via the prediction model tends to be biased. Bootstrapping is effective for generating a negative data set, for which the size and distribution are easily controlled. Our boosting algorithm could efficiently predict interacting motif pairs from protein interaction and sequence data, which was trained with the balanced data sets generated via the bootstrapping method.</p

Evidential Bagging: Combining Heterogeneous Classifiers in the Belief Functions Framework

International audienceIn machine learning, Ensemble Learning methodologies are known to improve predictive accuracy and robustness. They consist in the learning of many classifiers that produce outputs which are finally combined according to different techniques. Bagging, or Bootstrap Aggre-gating, is one of the most famous Ensemble methodologies and is usually applied to the same classification base algorithm, i.e. the same type of classifier is learnt multiple times on bootstrapped versions of the initial learning dataset. In this paper, we propose a bagging methodology that involves different types of classifier. Classifiers' probabilist outputs are used to build mass functions which are further combined within the belief functions framework. Three different ways of building mass functions are proposed; preliminary experiments on benchmark datasets showing the relevancy of the approach are presented

MegaSNPHunter: a learning approach to detect disease predisposition SNPs and high level interactions in genome wide association study

<p>Abstract</p> <p>Background</p> <p>The interactions of multiple single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) are highly hypothesized to affect an individual's susceptibility to complex diseases. Although many works have been done to identify and quantify the importance of multi-SNP interactions, few of them could handle the genome wide data due to the combinatorial explosive search space and the difficulty to statistically evaluate the high-order interactions given limited samples.</p> <p>Results</p> <p>Three comparative experiments are designed to evaluate the performance of MegaSNPHunter. The first experiment uses synthetic data generated on the basis of epistasis models. The second one uses a genome wide study on Parkinson disease (data acquired by using Illumina HumanHap300 SNP chips). The third one chooses the rheumatoid arthritis study from Wellcome Trust Case Control Consortium (WTCCC) using Affymetrix GeneChip 500K Mapping Array Set. MegaSNPHunter outperforms the best solution in this area and reports many potential interactions for the two real studies.</p> <p>Conclusion</p> <p>The experimental results on both synthetic data and two real data sets demonstrate that our proposed approach outperforms the best solution that is currently available in handling large-scale SNP data both in terms of speed and in terms of detection of potential interactions that were not identified before. To our knowledge, MegaSNPHunter is the first approach that is capable of identifying the disease-associated SNP interactions from WTCCC studies and is promising for practical disease prognosis.</p

ResBoost: characterizing and predicting catalytic residues in enzymes

Abstract Background Identifying the catalytic residues in enzymes can aid in understanding the molecular basis of an enzyme's function and has significant implications for designing new drugs, identifying genetic disorders, and engineering proteins with novel functions. Since experimentally determining catalytic sites is expensive, better computational methods for identifying catalytic residues are needed. Results We propose ResBoost, a new computational method to learn characteristics of catalytic residues. The method effectively selects and combines rules of thumb into a simple, easily interpretable logical expression that can be used for prediction. We formally define the rules of thumb that are often used to narrow the list of candidate residues, including residue evolutionary conservation, 3D clustering, solvent accessibility, and hydrophilicity. ResBoost builds on two methods from machine learning, the AdaBoost algorithm and Alternating Decision Trees, and provides precise control over the inherent trade-off between sensitivity and specificity. We evaluated ResBoost using cross-validation on a dataset of 100 enzymes from the hand-curated Catalytic Site Atlas (CSA). Conclusion ResBoost achieved 85% sensitivity for a 9.8% false positive rate and 73% sensitivity for a 5.7% false positive rate. ResBoost reduces the number of false positives by up to 56% compared to the use of evolutionary conservation scoring alone. We also illustrate the ability of ResBoost to identify recently validated catalytic residues not listed in the CSA

Learning pair-wise gene functional similarity by multiplex gene expression maps

Abstract Background The relationships between the gene functional similarity and gene expression profile, and between gene function annotation and gene sequence have been studied extensively. However, not much work has considered the connection between gene functions and location of a gene's expression in the mammalian tissues. On the other hand, although unsupervised learning methods have been commonly used in functional genomics, supervised learning cannot be directly applied to a set of normal genes without having a target (class) attribute. Results Here, we propose a supervised learning methodology to predict pair-wise gene functional similarity from multiplex gene expression maps that provide information about the location of gene expression. The features are extracted from expression maps and the labels denote the functional similarities of pairs of genes. We make use of wavelet features, original expression values, difference and average values of neighboring voxels and other features to perform boosting analysis. The experimental results show that with increasing similarities of gene expression maps, the functional similarities are increased too. The model predicts the functional similarities between genes to a certain degree. The weights of the features in the model indicate the features that are more significant for this prediction. Conclusions By considering pairs of genes, we propose a supervised learning methodology to predict pair-wise gene functional similarity from multiplex gene expression maps. We also explore the relationship between similarities of gene maps and gene functions. By using AdaBoost coupled with our proposed weak classifier we analyze a large-scale gene expression dataset and predict gene functional similarities. We also detect the most significant single voxels and pairs of neighboring voxels and visualize them in the expression map image of a mouse brain. This work is very important for predicting functions of unknown genes. It also has broader applicability since the methodology can be applied to analyze any large-scale dataset without a target attribute and is not restricted to gene expressions

Quantum adiabatic machine learning

We develop an approach to machine learning and anomaly detection via quantum adiabatic evolution. In the training phase we identify an optimal set of weak classifiers, to form a single strong classifier. In the testing phase we adiabatically evolve one or more strong classifiers on a superposition of inputs in order to find certain anomalous elements in the classification space. Both the training and testing phases are executed via quantum adiabatic evolution. We apply and illustrate this approach in detail to the problem of software verification and validation.Comment: 21 pages, 9 figure